Home > Policy and analysis > Reports > The future of the TEF: report to the independent reviewer

The future of the TEF: report to the independent reviewer

The future of the TEF


Universities UK's report on the overall effect the Teaching Excellence Framework (TEF) is having on higher education shows there is still some way to go to improve the system. 


Universities UK (UUK) calls on the government to reconsider plans for subject-level assessment following the challenges arising from the pilots in around 50 universities. UUK believes plans for subject-level TEF should not proceed until the limitations of the methodology, its resource impact, and the actual value of its contribution to student decision-making, have been fully considered. 

The report contributes to the independent review of the TEF being led by Dame Shirley Pearce. In it, UUK concludes:

  • The TEF is having an impact on the sector, in teaching and learning strategies and the monitoring of outcome measure.

  • It is hard to gather conclusive evidence of the TEF's contribution to teaching and learning experience and outcomes.

  • Its definition of excellence is weighted heavily towards employment outcomes, without full consideration of a student’s overall study experience and the wider benefits of teaching and learning for students and society

  • Awareness of the TEF is still low among students, while gradual and piecemeal changes have made it complicated for them to understand or to use it most effectively

  • New governance arrangements should be made to ensure the government, the Office for Students, students and providers have a clear stake in strategic decision-making.

  • A year into piloting subject-level assessment, there is considerable doubt over whether this will drive real value for students, while it is adding significant complexity and cost which could divert resource from other student-focused areas.



 

News

Thousands more should be able to do Degree Apprenticeships

15 July 2019
Bold action is needed from government to reform the degree apprenticeship system so many more people can become degree apprentices, according to a major report published today by Universities UK.

UUK response to the latest UCAS Undergraduate application figures

11 July 2019
Universities UK responds to the news that a record amount of young people in England are applying to study at university

Blog

First thoughts on Augar: plenty to discuss, but we must protect opportunity and choice

30 May 2019
Universities UK's Director of Policy Chris Hale takes a first look at the Augar review's long-awaited recommendations.

Women studying

University disciplinary processes under the microscope

8 February 2019
Ian Hynes, CEO of Intersol Global, discusses steps universities can take to improve their disciplinary processes.