Home > News and blog > Universities determined to review and prove value of degrees

Universities determined to review and prove value of degrees

Universities in England are developing a charter to help ensure they take a consistent and transparent approach to identifying and improving potentially low value or low quality courses.

Institutions already monitor and review their courses regularly and have robust processes in place to uphold quality and standards. Assessing value however is challenging, can be subjective and may involve areas such as graduate career satisfaction or employment outcomes many years after graduation.

Development of the charter, led by a Universities UK advisory group, will initially focus on the following areas:

  • Demonstrating the sector's commitment to consistency and transparency in processes to tackle low value courses through the publication of a Statement of Intent, agreed by universities.
  • Highlighting best practice where universities are already identifying low value or low quality courses, including the use of metrics, and taking rapid action to address issues.

Following this work, Universities UK will publish guidance which universities will be expected to follow.

In the longer term, universities will also consider options for external assurance or independent review to make their processes stronger as part of an ongoing charter.

Professor Julia Buckingham, President of Universities UK and Chair of the advisory group said: "The overwhelming majority of courses are high quality and offer good value for students, but we want to address concerns that some could deliver more for students, taxpayers, and employers.

"The development of this charter will help universities take consistent and more transparent approaches in tackling low quality or low value courses.

"The public needs full confidence in the value and quality of a UK university degree and the charter will demonstrate universities' commitment to constant improvement."


As of 13 November, the advisory group comprises of the following UUK members:

  • Professor Julia Buckingham CBE (Chair of advisory group), Brunel University London
  • Professor Graham Baldwin, University of Central Lancashire
  • Professor Dame Janet Beer DBE, University of Liverpool
  • Professor Frances Corner OBE, Goldsmiths University of London
  • Professor Susan Lea, University of Hull
  • Professor Edward Peck, Nottingham Trent University
  • Professor Malcolm Press, Manchester Metropolitan University
  • Professor Lisa Roberts,  University of Exeter
  • Professor Andy Schofield, Lancaster University
  • Professor Mark Smith CBE, University of Southampton
  • Professor Wendy Thomson CBE, University of London

Our team

Steven Jefferies

Steven Jefferies

Head of Media
Universities UK

Luke Lambert

Luke Lambert

Press and Social Media Officer
Universities UK

Clara Plackett

Clara Plackett

Senior Press and Social Media Officer
Universities UK



Pathways and flexibility are key to supporting lifelong learning

18 December 2020
Dave Phoenix, Vice-Chancellor of London South Bank University, argues that if we are to facilitate lifelong learning and avoid ‘educational dead ends’, universities must play a core role in qualification design.

The grades u-turn caused a ripple effect throughout education – it could be catastrophic for unis

25 August 2020
From over-stretched finances to lack of space and facilities, universities are facing a perfect storm of problems.


UUK response to government’s interim response to the Augar review, post-qualifications admissions consultation and TEF

21 January 2021
UUK has responded to government’s interim response to the Augar review, post-qualifications admissions consultation and TEF

UUK logo

UUK response to the government’s latest January return plans for university students

30 December 2020
UUK has responded to the Secretary of State for Education Gavin Williamson's latest announcement on the return of students to universities in January 2021.