Home > News and blog > Approach to judging the ‘value’ of a degree needs overhaul

Approach to judging the ‘value’ of a degree needs overhaul

Universities UK’s President speaks out about higher education’s need to better explain its benefits.

Measures used to assess the value of a degree course could be completely overhauled under proposals to government put forward by Universities UK (UUK).

In future, government and universities would be able to use a new tool which measures the value of individual subjects beyond just graduate earnings. This could be to the benefit of students themselves as well as to wider society and the economy.

In a major speech on the topic of value in higher education, UUK President Professor Julia Buckingham called on government to broaden its definition of 'value' beyond a student's expected future salary alone and to recognise the less celebrated, yet vital benefits of studying for a degree. She also issued a rallying call to the sector to do more to address concerns around value and respond more effectively where there are legitimate concerns.

To support the government in adopting a new approach, UUK is outlining proposed new measures against which it believes universities can demonstrate the success and contribution of their courses. These include the proportion of graduates working in essential public services, the number taking positions in sectors and regions with skills shortages, or the likelihood of a graduate starting their own business. The tool would allow universities to assess and illustrate the wider benefits to students of university life, such as their life satisfaction, personal health and opportunities to get involved in volunteer work.


Professor Julia Buckingham, President of Universities UK and Vice-Chancellor of Brunel University London, said:

"While universities need to work collectively and respond more effectively to legitimate challenges around the value of some university degrees, government also needs to broaden its current narrow definition of success based on salaries alone. This is a blunt tool which does a disservice to students and recent graduates, while failing to consider the wider student experience.

"A much broader approach which takes account the other benefits of a university degree would better reflect what is important to students, parents, employers and society.

"We need to look beyond an individual's P60 and think about the total package of what they have learnt and achieved through their time at university."

As part of its response to the Augar Review of post-18 education and funding, UUK established a number of Vice-Chancellor working groups to consider the issues raised in the report.

Following research showing that students themselves do not see future salary as the driving factor in their higher education choices, the group exploring the value of a university education is committed to making the case to government to adopt a broader definition. This new framework will shortly be presented to government to help identify what the wider themes of that approach might be.

 

A comment piece from Professor Julia Buckingham on this topic, as run in the Daily Telegraph is available here: Professor Buckingham OpEd on value of higher education.pdf


Notes:

  1. Professor Julia Buckingham is giving the keynote address at Advance HE's 'Let's talk value' conference in London. The full speech is available on request from the UUK media team.

  2. In September, Universities UK commissioned Savanta ComRes to carry out research which found 84% of students and recent graduates agreed that future salary was not the only factor in choosing their degree. Eight in 10 surveyed thought the government should do more to promote the wider benefits of studying at university and define them more broadly than by future earnings alone. 

  3. Currently the government's analysis of educational outcomes known as LEO (Longitudinal educational outcomes) is based on predicted future earnings. Various concerns have been raised about this approach, including from the minister who originally commissioned the project.

  4. Universities UK is running an event on the value of higher education in April. For more information or to book your place, click here.

  5. Universities UK is the collective voice of 137 universities in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Its mission is to create the conditions for UK universities to be the best in the world; maximising their positive impact locally, nationally and globally. Universities UK acts on behalf of universities, represented by their heads of institution. Visit: www.universitiesuk.ac.uk

     

     



 

Our team

Jo Hindle

Jo Hindle

Head of Media
Universities UK

Luke Lambert

Luke Lambert

Press and Social Media Officer
Universities UK

Clara Plackett

Clara Plackett

Senior Press and Social Media Officer
Universities UK

Blog

a student against a background of stripes

Presenting university income and spending to students

21 October 2019
David Phoenix on the importance of universities presenting their financial information to students.

Universities must help secure a sustainable future for our planet

4 April 2019
The University of Edinburgh's Dave Gorman on the steps his institution is taking to reduce carbon emissions and make a sustainable and socially responsible contribution to the world.

News


Filling careers advice gaps would make university applications fairer

17 February 2020
​The majority of students and recent graduates believe the university application process is fair, however the support they receive making their career choices is a concern for many.